Skip to main content

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

The Brexit elite enjoyed Europe. So why do they hate the idea of young Britons working there?

The hypocrisy of Nigel Farage and co over youth mobility is rooted in class and our refusal to learn other languages

'As ever in Brexit discourse, Britain is the victim.' Image: TNW/Getty

Prod the tough English hide of a veteran Brexiteer and you will often find something quite incongruous. Nigel Farage? A German second wife, and a French girlfriend. Boris Johnson? Born in New York and spent part of his childhood in Brussels. Suella Braverman? Took a master’s in law from the Sorbonne. Robert Jenrick? Studied in Pennsylvania, married to an Israeli-American.

We cannot, of course, say whether Jeremy Corbyn voted Leave, but we do know that his second wife was Chilean and his current spouse comes from Mexico. At one point they had a cat called El Gato.

These are people who have benefited from the freedom to work and study abroad, and their choice of partners reflects it. But they nonetheless believe that freedom is harmful to the average Briton. 

These are people who have benefited from the freedom to work and study abroad, and their choice of partners reflects it. But they nonetheless believe that freedom is harmful to the average Briton. “Open Borders Burnham is betraying our young people,” fumed Farage, at the prospect of a Youth Experience Scheme that will enable 100,000 Britons to work in the EU temporarily, with a reciprocal right for EU youth.

The origins of this hypocrisy lie in two British characteristics: our reluctance to learn foreign languages, and the way class is deployed in UK politics. Because so few of us now speak a European language to a decent level, our ability to live and work in Europe is curtailed. 

Those who can get by in a European language were often privately educated. Westminster School teaches nine languages, Eton seven, with more if staffing permits it. Most Britons get to try one.

This doesn’t mean Britain isn’t becoming a more multilingual society. Immigrants and their children often speak community languages. (Search for “Polish Saturday school” for instance; if you’re not of Polish heritage, you may be surprised by how many there are.) But these remain a mystery to Britons outside those communities. 

This means that freedom of movement can be portrayed as an elite benefit and not something that ordinary Britons could enjoy. It becomes another of the resentments stoked by populist politics: if I can’t have it, why should you? They come over here, but there’s no way I could go over there.

Europeans do not see it this way. Generally, freedom of movement is not class-coded, as it tends to be in the UK. 

The central and eastern Europeans who have moved to Britain since 2004 did not see poor English as an obstacle, any more than Britons moving to Spain worry about conjugating Spanish verbs. The imperative to get work and start a new life was more important. And maybe 100,000 young Britons under 32 will get the chance to feel the same way.

It will be tough at first. Germany has indicated a willingness to take tens of thousands of Britons, but only 2,294 students sat A-level German this year. 

Still, it has never been easier to learn a language. You can do it on your phone, and stream endless audio and video for free.

Yet the Brexiteers will once again tell us freedom of movement is something that only the well-off and foreigners benefit from. “If Andy Burnham is serious about tackling the crisis faced by the one million Neets, then he should not be opening the door to thousands of Europeans to come and take those jobs that do exist,” Iain Duncan Smith told the Daily Mail.

At no point did the Mail suggest that unemployed British youth might want to go and work in Europe. If they did, it would take them off the jobless register and cut the benefits bill, as well as offering the skills and work experience that British employers say they can no longer afford to give them. 

But, as ever in Brexit discourse, Britain is the victim, condemned to hire foreigners while our own youth fester, unable to take up the opportunities available to them. It is the same old passivity, repackaged for the Neets era.

The irony is that Britain already has reciprocal youth employment schemes with a number of countries – the biggest are with Australia, New Zealand, South Korea, Canada and Japan – which together offer around 72,000 places each year. Up to a thousand 18-30s can even go to Iceland, ho ho. 

None of these schemes attracts any of the fury that has greeted the deal with the EU. Indeed, the number of migrants who use them to come to Britain is less than you might expect – just 24,306 in 2024. 

And we do not even bother to track the number of British citizens who go abroad under these schemes. Who could possibly be interested in that? A Lib Dem peer asked the Home Office that question last year, and was told the data “could only be collected and verified… at disproportionate cost.”

Fury at the thought of EU youth visiting Britain; complete indifference to how many of our own under-30s travel the other way. And to cap it all, a refusal to extend the opportunities that older generations enjoyed to Gen Z. What could better illustrate Britain’s attitude towards young people?

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.