Skip to main content

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

Immigration – the problem that isn’t really there

The political challenge the prime minister faces is to show voters that the problem of immigration exists differently to how they believe it does

Immigration is a vast public issue - how do the government tackle this? Image: TNW/Getty

Like it or not, immigration is a massive public concern, rivalling the economy as voters’ top issue, way ahead of health, crime and welfare. 

Each week YouGov presents respondents with a list of 18 subjects and asks them to say which three “are the most important issues facing the country at this time”. In its latest survey, the economy scores 51% and immigration 48%. Health is way behind in third place on 24%.

The figure for immigration has doubled, from 24%, in the past four years. It has slipped a little since its peak of 56% a year ago, but remains historically high, despite the sharp fall in net migration.

A separate YouGov survey adds to the mystery. Last year it asked people whether they had a positive or negative view of different groups of immigrants. For all kinds of workers, and also students, the “positives” far outweighed the “negatives”. For those coming to live with their families, the positives remain ahead but more narrowly. It’s people arriving by small boats to seek asylum whom we view most negatively.

Given this, why are voters so het up about immigration when the numbers are falling? An Ipsos survey from two years ago explained why. (I doubt a more recent survey would have given significantly different results.)

Ipsos asked respondents what percentage of immigrants in each of four categories had come to Britain the previous year. These are the average figures for what voters thought, compared with the actual number recorded by the Office for National Statistics:

To work: what voters thought, 26%; actual share, 40%

To study: voters, 19%; actual, 38%

To apply for asylum/refugee status: voters, 37%; actual 7%

To live with their family/partner: voters, 17%, actual 6%

So the two groups viewed most positively – workers and students – comprised 78% of all new immigrants, but were believed to make up just 45%. In contrast, the two less popular groups – immigrants wanting asylum or to join their family – comprise just 13% of all new immigrants, but were believed to comprise a majority, 54%.

The real political issue is not that most voters dislike immigrants, or that the numbers are too high. It’s that they think immigration is a problem that is out of control. The government’s greatest challenge is changing that perception.

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

See inside the Bloody Immigrants edition

Germany’s Social Democrats are sinking in the polls, with an internal leadership battle threatening to make matters worse. Image: TNW/Getty

Germansplaining: Germany’s social democrats are in a death spiral – and now there’s more in-fighting

A battle at the top of the party is coming in January as it slumps to just 13% in the polls

Despite voters rejecting foreign military bases, the US is expanding its military presence in Ecuador. Image: TNW/Getty

The country that voted to keep Trump out – but he’s moving in anyway

Ecuador’s voters said they didn’t want American military bases on its soil. But now it seems the country’s hard right leader has other ideas