With 5.29 million listeners – including most of Parliament, business and civil society – presenting the Today programme should be the biggest gig available to any British radio journalist. So why does it seem nobody wants to do it?
Emma Barnett will this week be the latest high-profile departure from the programme, leaving after less than six years for a “bold” new show launching next year across BBC Sounds, iPlayer and YouTube. Insiders have stressed it is a step up for the ambitious Barnett, but her tenure at the show was dogged by rumours of a difficult relationship with fellow host Nick Robinson. At one point 90 days passed without the pair presenting together.
But Barnett is just the latest in a line of Today presenters who have decided the grass is greener elsewhere. To listeners’ dismay, Mishal Husain left the programme in December 2024 after 11 years for a bigger salary but smaller audience at Bloomberg, where she presents The Mishal Husain Show, a weekly podcast.
Last month she told the Times: “Was it a happy programme to work on? I think… ‘happy’ is quite a hard adjective to attach to the programme because people are very exacting of themselves.”
And in September this year, Amol Rajan left to reinvent himself as a content creator. Following a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it appearance on The Celebrity Traitors, he launched the YouTube show The Amol Rajan Connection with the modest aim of building “the most useful platform for ideas anywhere in the world”.
Suggested Reading
The Mail’s embarrassing apology for its misleading jobs headline
It all means Today bosses have once again embarked on a search for a new voice to present alongside the rotating line-up of Robinson, Justin Webb and Anna Foster. Culture and media editor (and daughter of Liberal Democrat peer Tim) Katie Razzall is thought to be the favourite, ahead of Europe editor Katya Adler. Were the BBC to go outside the corporation, ITV’s Julie Etchingham and Sky News’s Sophy Ridge are said to be possibilities.
But how long would any of them last? To lose one star presenter may be regarded as a misfortune; to lose three in such short order suggests that the Today programme is not a happy ship…
