“Four out of five new jobs went to foreigners in the past decade” ran the Daily Mail’s front page headline on October 14, as the paper fulminated that Brits were being crowded out of the job market.
The figure was based on a report from the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ), a right wing think tank founded by Iain Duncan Smith, and used official HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) data. But while the underlying figures were genuine, the headline gave readers a seriously misleading impression of how Britain’s employment market actually works.
According to the CSJ, the number of payroll jobs increased by approximately 3.7 million between 2014 and December 2025, with 408,000 going to EU nationals and 2.5 million to non-British, non-EU nationals – broadly giving the Mail its four-out-of-five figure.
But the vital context missing from the Mail’s interpretation is that new jobs are not the same as newly hired workers. While HMRC’s statistics measure the number of PAYE employment positions recorded at different points in time, they do not track every job advertised, every application submitted or every decision made by an employer.
Suggested Reading
Michael Gove gets the old Vote Leave band back together
The 3.7 million figure represents the approximate net increase in recorded payroll employment positions over the period – which is very much not the same as being able to claim that four out of every five individual vacancies were awarded to someone from overseas. In fact, HMRC says 80% of payroll jobs are held by UK nationals.
Now, following a complaint about its misleading headline from the King’s College London academic Jonathan Portes, the Mail has published an embarrassing mea culpa, acknowledging that its splash was statistical drivel.
On page 2 of its print edition on Monday, the Mail told readers: “On 14 October our front page headline stated that ‘four out of five new jobs went to foreigners in the past decade’. This was based on a report by the Centre for Social Justice.
“However, the HMRC data analysed by the think-tank relate to net changes in employment (the number of people in payroll jobs, broken down by nationality).
“In fact, net changes in employment, which reflect the balance of both new hires and exits from employment, do not correspond to ‘new jobs’. The vast majority of both new hires and exits are British nationals.
“We regret this error, particularly since it was made repeatedly before, and corrected, both by this newspaper and by others in the mid-2010s. We have taken steps to make sure that it is not repeated again.”
Oof! Perhaps it is time someone made a sharp exit at the Mail?
