A few years ago, I was asked by the Goethe Institute to do a video discussion with a woman who had a different view on Brexit. Fair enough, I thought, and didn’t enquire much about the details.
The woman was in and out of sheltered accommodation, in and out of work. Single mum from the East Midlands versus posh git from North London. At every turn she had been let down by the authorities.
I was moved, and told her so, but added, ever so respectfully, that surely this was the fault of her local council or the national government. What did Brussels have to do with her woes?
At which point she exploded: “I’m so sick of people like you, with all your facts. I’m talking about my emotions”.
I didn’t come across well. What is the German for being stitched up like a kipper? I should have learnt, but it transpires that I didn’t.
In September I agreed to take part in a debate organised by the Spectator; date November 17. They offered me the magazine Diary – a nice slot – and so I accepted and thought not much more about it.
My partner in crime would be the journalist, Sarfraz Manzoor. Proposing the motion “this House believes that multiculturalism has failed” would be Suella Braverman and columnist Melanie Phillips.
I girded my loins. I assumed it would be tough. Given the hosts, the audience would be right wing and heavily skewed against us.
I assumed it would be rational. Instead, it was bloodlust. You might well ask: “Where have you been? What did you expect?”
Don’t laugh, but I began with a spot of poetry.
A true-born Englishman’s a contradiction,
In speech an irony, in fact a fiction…
Since scarce one family is left alive,
Which does not from some foreigner derive.
What I was trying to say, courtesy of Daniel Defoe in 1701, is that there is no such thing as the pure Englishman or Briton. I pointed out that of the 1400 tenants-in-chief named in the Domesday Book who held their lands directly from the king, only 13 nobles (fewer than one per cent) could claim Anglo-Saxon heritage.
As for our royal family, we know they’re all Krauts… we are all, I suggested, migrants of a sort.
I talked about my own heritage: Jewish father from Bratislava fleeing the Nazis meets working-class Protestant mother from Chatham in the British military ward in Singapore, where I was born. Throw in a gaggle of Mexican Catholic relatives, courtesy of a Cornish silver mining company (would take too long to explain), plus living in Berlin, now British and German, and what am I?
A Citizen of Nowhere, as Theresa May would have called me, or as I prefer to describe myself (and my Substack) a Citizen of Everywhere.
As the 90 minutes ground on, our opponents became increasingly agitated. Braverman seemed on the edge of tears as she declared that good (white) Britons had become strangers in their homeland. She took us on an angry tour of a country where women were clad in burkas, where polygamy was practised, where female genital mutilation was rife.
Every statement of hers was cheered to the rafters. Then she turned to me, demanding to know why I had called her a racist. I hadn’t.
Phillips suggested at one point that we all had more in common than we realised. We surely believed in the need for integration – yes, we did – and we believed in the need for migrants to speak English. We did that too, though I pointed out that it would be nice if Brits abroad bothered to learn Jonny Foreigner’s language.
Her interventions would begin calmly, before the indignation got the better of her. I should also feel ashamed of being “a citizen of everywhere”, she declared, adding that I clearly had no love for this country and wouldn’t fight for it. I said that I would fight alongside anyone defending liberal democracy from Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and other supporters of the far right.
None of this was going down well. So, to questions: first up, an agitated man who asked Manzoor whether he could give him a blank sheet of paper so that he could draw a picture of the Prophet Mohammed, to which my comrade-in-arms responded. “No, but I can draw a picture of a racist fuckwit”. The boos in our direction grew louder.
Michael Gove, the Spectator editor, took what you might you call a light-touch chairing approach. All is fair in the Spectator-land of “free speech”.
He did at one point seek a reconciliation of sorts. Were we not all united in our view that Britain was the greatest country on earth? In search of a moment of calm, I produced my best rictus grin.
Manzoor played bad cop, pantomime villain (to this lot), and he played it with panache. I tried to play good cop, Mr Quiet Reason, and my approach only antagonised.
Only once did we seem to discomfit our opponents, when we invited them to discuss the era when the Britain “of Constable, pale ale and the Army” was last truly Great. Phillips struggled for an answer, before suggesting the year 1996, before that dangerous radical Tony Blair took power. She and Braverman were also curiously reluctant to respond when asked if they wanted to emulate Trump in sending in ICE-style troops to take people violently off the streets.
I missed some tricks. I should have engaged more in the specifics of their claims around two-tier policing and other Reform trigger points, rather than ceding the ground to them unchallenged.
Suggested Reading
Net migration is over. Now what?
I wanted to invite them to comment on the great multicultural successes of the midterms – more Black governors than ever in US history, the Hispanic governor in Texas and in California, New Mexico’s first Native American governor. And of course, the Muslim in Michigan who goes by the name “Call me Senator”. I forgot these lines and others.
I’m not sure ultimately it mattered. At the start, the 400-or-so-strong audience voted 71 per cent to 29 for the motion. At the end, it had firmed up to 75 per cent. I speculated plaintively that the dozen or so people who walked out during the debate might have been taken aback by the fury.
I doubt anyone changed their minds; they were here for the performance, not for rational debate.
Was it worth the investment of a dank evening in Westminster? The Spectator might have got a few new, odd subscriptions, and some clickbait for their website. Mel and Suel will have delighted their fans.
And I learnt that I should get out of my bubble more. It’s one thing to opine about democratic backsliding and the rise of the far right, it’s quite another to see it up close and personal.
