The leaders of the US, China and Russia sat around a giant, donut-shaped wooden table in Shenzhen and, for Trump, it was a chance for a lame-duck president to parade on the world stage with two strongmen.
There had been much talk of a summit to match the Yalta conference of 1945, when the leaders of the US, Britain and the USSR decided how to carve up the post-war world. But the Trump-Xi-Putin threesome was nothing of the sort.
There were almost no concrete results from the 80-minute meeting in a villa in Shenzhen – no clear breakthroughs. Nothing to announce on Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, nothing on Trump’s war on Iran. Just a four-point “Declaration toward Peace” that echoed many of Beijing and Moscow’s talking points. But Trump was happy. Very happy.
US presidents often turn to foreign policy in their last two years after a midterms defeat, and Trump appears to be no exception.
“We are really making history,” Trump declared, reading out a statement in the stilted way he does on those big occasions when he’s forced to stick to the script instead of embarking on one of his trademark rambling “weaves”.
Suggested Reading
The mood in the White House is grim – and I know because I’ve been there
Trump also tried to justify the fact that he was meeting America’s biggest adversaries, despite criticism at home and from Washington’s allies, including Ukraine. He did so by casting the summit as the leaders of the great powers sorting out the big issues affecting the rest of the world.
“As presidents of three of the world’s largest countries, we have a special responsibility to maintain open, respectful, and productive dialogue on issues impacting not just our people but the entire planet,” Trump proclaimed. “No problems were ever solved under the old school refusing to talk about them.”
Yet Trump couldn’t help admitting how much the pomp mattered to him. In a Fox News interview before the trilateral, when asked what he thought the headline from his visit would be, he said: “I think I’ve already gotten that headline.” Referring to Xi, Trump remarked: “He’s never gone to the airport to meet somebody.”
Throughout his time in Shenzhen, Trump’s attempts to flaunt his camaraderie with his authoritarian pals produced a string of those meme-friendly moments. “Who is he? He’s my friend,” a chuckling Trump said in mock surprise as he greeted Putin in a separate one-on-one meeting.
Those words may come back to haunt him. Trump’s self-professed friendship with Putin has always been puzzling, and indeed led to the Robert Mueller investigation that dominated his first presidency.
The Democrats, who won control of Congress in the midterms, are about to take maximum advantage of the fact to bring Trump’s administration to account. They took notice of his behaviour with Putin and Xi.
“It’s a betrayal of the United States by a president who loves nothing more than to bow down to our adversaries for a photo op,” said Chuck Schumer, the current Democratic minority leader in the Senate.
But though Trump may turn to foreign policy as his power ebbs at home, he could still find it hard to achieve much abroad. He hailed what he called a “Great and Highly Consequential Trip” in a post on Truth Social as he flew home on Air Force One – yet there was little he could point to in terms of actual results.
Suggested Reading
Trump was only the warm-up guy for America’s new right
Trump went into the event saying he wanted to make progress on nuclear disarmament. But the “Declaration toward Peace” merely said that the three leaders “reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” and that they would keep talking about it.
The wording counts as a win for China, which has dragged its feet on disarmament as it seeks to catch up with the US and Russia on warheads. Putin, meanwhile, could be seen distractedly toying with a glass of water as Trump talked about nuclear weapons and Iran. As for Ukraine, there was no mention at all.
While Trump saw himself as part of a powerful triumvirate, Xi had other ideas. The Chinese leader lorded it over his guests in a carefully choreographed display of Beijing’s rising power. While the King Arthur-style round table was meant to symbolise equality, the set-up unquestionably placed Xi firmly at its head.
Xi had no one opposite him except the world’s cameras, while Trump and Putin appeared relegated to bit players, staring at each other over a huge centerpiece of pink and purple flowers.
With the US bogged down in Iran and Russia grinding on with its war in Ukraine, Xi was able to present China as the face of stability and calm.
But Putin will also be pleased with what he got out of this summit. Not only some backslapping bonhomie from Trump, but the thing he has craved more than anything since the invasion of Ukraine – a return from international isolation. In Putin’s view, Moscow finally has its deserved seat at the table with the big boys.
And when Trump remarked: “I’ll be suggesting ways to protect our nation’s sovereignty from rogue globalist organizations such as the International Criminal Court,” it will have been music to Putin’s ears. The ICC has issued a warrant for the Russian leader’s arrest for war crimes in Ukraine.
They can dodge the ICC – but neither Trump nor Putin can avoid the trouble back home. Trump’s inner circle are bracing themselves for investigations by a Democrat-led Congress, and the Iran war refuses to go away. As for Putin, Ukraine is continuing its resistance against his army, and Zelensky still rejects US pressure to submit to a deal.
Still, Trump has invited both Xi and Putin to the G20 summit at his Doral resort in Miami next month. It seems the US president can count on his authoritarian friends abroad for a diplomatic threesome. There don’t seem to be many takers anywhere else.
