The potential bursting of the AI bubble, the hottest show on Disney+ and a petty YouTube drama – what do these three things dominating recent headlines have in common? Affairs.
Ethan Klein, the podcaster and YouTuber with more than five million subscribers, has found himself at the centre of an internet meltdown after his wife Hila publicly accused him of having an affair. Meanwhile, Disney+’s Rivals, a programme in which marital fidelity is flouted at every turn, has returned and is one of the platform’s biggest hits.
And then there’s Jensen Huang, the (now former) CEO of Nvidia, who is reported to have had not one, not two, but three extramarital affairs – one with an alleged Chinese spy. This one has provided the internet with some of its best memes of the year, alongside far more serious questions surrounding the potential security breach – now being investigated by the FBI – and the financial implications of such an important company falling into chaos.
Three very different affairs, and three very different reactions. Klein’s alleged betrayal has prompted an extraordinary level of public condemnation, with many fans vowing never to watch him again, on account of feeling betrayed by his deception.
Rivals, by contrast, is adored, although some viewers have noted that Rupert Campbell-Black’s caddish character on screen is softer than portrayed in Jilly Cooper’s original novels. This makes him more palatable as a romantic prospect for the pure-of-heart Taggie.
Huang, meanwhile, has largely been treated as a benign, occasionally legendary, source of internet humour. Examples include video parodies of him ranking the looks of his various mistresses and generally making him out to be an all round casanova, set to “It wasn’t me,” by Shaggy.
There is something peculiar about our relationship with infidelity, particularly among Gen Z. Cheating has always been considered a fairly serious relationship transgression, but in the online world inhabited by the young, it increasingly seems to rank alongside the most heinous moral crimes imaginable.
Take John Mulaney. The comedian divorced his first wife during a period in rehab, subsequently entered a relationship with Olivia Munn and had a child with her. He is now happily married, with two children, and there has been no suggestion of wrongdoing in the breakdown of his first marriage.
Yet scroll through almost any clip of his stand-up or Saturday Night Live appearances and the top comment will invariably be some variation of a twenty-something explaining their internal conflict about finding him funny while being unable to condone cheaters. The poor man is apparently permitted to be amusing, but only under moral supervision.
Then there were the so-called “cheating lawyers”, the two professionals filmed kissing in Central Park, one of whom turned out to be married. The incident prompted an extraordinary online backlash, with much of the discussion, particularly among younger users, centring on whether the relationship was predatory and how the individuals deserved professional consequences (both ended up losing their jobs). In both cases, private affairs became an opportunity for those online to stage a public morality play.
Part of this might be explained by the fact that we have fundamentally changed what cheating actually means. Traditionally, it was relatively straightforward: sexual relationship outside an exclusive partnership. Now there is emotional cheating, microcheating and the increasingly contentious concept of work wives and husbands.
Suggested Reading
Nicki Minaj’s credibility is Trump’s latest victim
Emotional cheating, for example, describes developing an intimate emotional connection with someone outside your relationship, particularly where that connection is concealed from your partner.
Microcheating takes things further still, including behaviours such as secretly messaging an ex, liking racy Instagram posts or maintaining dating-app profiles. Even having a particularly close friendship with a colleague can apparently constitute a betrayal, depending on which corner of TikTok you happen to find yourself in. So, when there are all these lower stakes ways to cheat that are condemned wholeheartedly, a full blown affair is like a nuclear bomb.
There is also something to be said about the fact that, although society has become less religious, people’s appetite for moral strictures has not necessarily gone away. Social media has rather taken on the mantle of a religious order, developing its own secular moral framework, complete with transgressions, excommunications (cancel culture), and public confessions.
But in a more progressive time, when most of the old sticking points of organised religion, such as sex outside marriage, homosexuality and blasphemy, have quite rightly been normalised, infidelity seems to be the last bastion of traditional sexual morality. The last sin, perhaps, that even the most progressive corners of the internet can agree is unforgivable.
And of course, in an increasingly complicated and frightening world, having a clear set of moral rules can be comforting. Cheating is wrong, cheaters are bad, and anyone who continues to enjoy the work of these unfaithful people is perhaps a little morally suspect themselves. It is an easy way to demonstrate one’s own virtue, an impulse central to all religions, Abrahamic or Instagramic.
Or perhaps most of this is simply down to being young. It is considerably easier to have uncompromising views on marriage and infidelity when you have yet to experience a long-term relationship, or the general complications of adult life.
But none of this really explains the curious case of Jensen Huang. Why is the internet seemingly more interested in the moral character of a YouTuber than the conduct of one of the most powerful men in the global economy? Klein’s alleged affair is a private family matter, albeit one with obvious consequences for his business and public reputation. Huang’s position, by contrast, raises questions with potentially enormous financial and national security implications. Yet one has become a villain, while the other has become a meme.
Maybe it is because audiences feel that they know Ethan Klein, they have spent years treating him as a familiar presence in their lives. Huang, meanwhile, is a billionaire in a leather jacket. His personal life is largely irrelevant to our relationship with him, even if his professional decisions have considerably greater implications for us.
Perhaps, then, Gen Z’s relationship with infidelity isn’t really about sex, marriage or even morality. It is about proximity. We are much more interested in the private failings of people we feel we know than the public failings of people whose decisions might actually affect us.
We are, in other words, more bothered about policing the bedroom than the boardroom.
