Re: “Beating Trump isn’t the wild triumph you think it is” by Slavoj Žižek, TNW #505
I agree that this is no time for triumphalism in the US. Not only is Donald Trump still in the White House, but the Democrats are not entirely united and cannot call all the shots – and there is an awful lot for them to do.
I am not even sure that the Democrats collectively understand the extent to which the constitution is out of date. The system of checks and balances is little more than a gentlemen’s agreement.
Adam Bukolt
Fantastic. The point about fetishising Trump is absolutely spot on. And as a person of Czech origin, I love the fact that Havel’s words are still alive and kicking!
Super pleased that Slavoj now writes for TNW. It made me renew my subscription.
Leona Merclova
The mistake is to believe that Trump and the Republican Party are the same thing and that therefore, when the Republicans lose, Trump loses. At this point, Trump and those who follow him are a distinct and separate thing.
Bob
It is quite possible to feel joy (wild or not) for the midterms swing and to understand that the great task of transformation remains. You can hold both at the same time.
Paul Carvajal
Re: “Who’s next? The race to save the Republicans” by Charlotte McDonald-Gibson, TNW #505
Perhaps JD Vance’s best hope is that the grim reaper intervenes to offer him the crown by default and he would fight the next election as the incumbent.
Brian Ronson

Re: “Watching the midterm rout with New York’s MAGA hardcore,” by Marie Le Conte, TNW #505
Thanks for going to the Republican bash, Marie, so we didn’t have to.
Al Blake
Re: “How US pollsters got it wrong” by Peter Kellner, TNW #505
Like the media, polls focus on people who have time on their hands – the oldies. Good to see young people taking their futures to the ballet box.
Robert Wade
Re: Rats in a Sack on Nigel Farage’s midterm prediction, TNW #505
Farage’s verdict of “Trump won’t get smashed” is not so much a case of Nostradamus as Nostradumbass.
Kenny MacLeod
I find a useful rule of thumb to apply is that Farage is always wrong about everything. This saves me loads of time as I can simply ignore him.
Susanne Jarratt
Re: “The great American techlash” by James Ball, TNW #505
The fact that voters are exercised over data centres should not be seen as strange. The development of AI is clearly out of hand and instead of the assumed liberation of the internet, AI is primarily an element of war, control and misinformation.
Keith Brisley
Re: “The reckoning I thought Russell Brand would never face,” by Lucy Reade, TNW #505
That’s the best bit of journalism in this arena I have ever seen.
Robert Hamer
A truly sickening account of yet another man who believed himself above the law. To all those who supported him, and particularly the women, shame on you all.
Louise Nicholls
A great article. I doubted that Brand would be found guilty as so often these despicable monsters are believed over their accusers. But the women were believed and justice has been served.
The judge’s summing up was powerful and should be shouted from the rooftops.
Sarah Lea
This is the best analysis on the Brand case that I’ve read, and I’m grateful to Lucy Reade for sitting through this in court to report on it in such a considered way. Those women are heroic for standing up and having to repeat their trauma over and over again.
How many more offenders are still lurking about in media circles? I hope that more of the coverage can be as thoughtful as your piece.
Emma Owen Davies
Suggested Reading
Why does everyone hate Laura Kuenssberg?
Re: “The case for Laura Kuenssberg” by Ros Taylor, TNW #505
My biggest and wholly unoriginal criticism of Laura Kuenssberg is that she and many of the key BBC political programmes are more interested in the drama of conflict than in policy. I love political gossip as much as the next reader, but it fosters a culture based on personalities and chasing clicks rather than exploring ideas.
Marcel Reinard
Laura Kuenssberg quite rightly talks about the critical importance of preserving a “shared reality”. Yet in an era where millions of people will pay good money for long form, in-depth journalism and context through (for example) TNW, podcasts and Substack, her Sunday show provides little of those crucial qualities.
She chooses instead to speed-date a politician for 10 minutes, resulting in a series of cheap-shot clips that go viral, fuel the culture war and further erode the very thing she deems so crucial.
Andy Davies
Re: “The John Lewis Christmas ad meltdown is Britain’s most idiotic new tradition” by Mic Wright, TNW #505
The John Lewis Xmas ads are usually at the edge of what will be fashionable, and having had the pleasure of working with some of their buyers and designers, I know they really want to set trends, not follow them.
So, sorry Sarah Vine, Piers Morgan, Allison Pearson et al, but it looks like next year’s trend is “woke”.
Christopher Harrison
If I worked for John Lewis’s publicity department I would deliberately wind up the reactionary right wing every Xmas: gay dads, Polish grandparents, lesbian daughter, Caribbean Santa in a cycle lane, Muslim neighbours, copy of TNW on the coffee table, EU flag on the tree. I’d give them lock, stock and two smoking barrels of wokery every Christmas.
Richard Riddle
BELOW THE LINE
Re: Alastair Campbell’s Diary on youth clubs, TNW #505
I agree wholeheartedly with your comments on youth clubs as a force for good. I would say that I grew up in one; we played games for sure, but also learned about teamwork, taking responsibility and how the combustion engine works! We made stuff, too, and applied to the Prince’s Trust for £50 to build a canoe, and from that a club of now 45 years’ standing was born.
I owe my career to the start those youth leaders and that education gave me. Let’s get them properly funded.
William Smyth
I spent many years working in youth clubs. Most of the young people just wanted a place to hang out and relax and an adult they could talk to about all sorts of things without being judged or told what to do. We have done our young people a great disservice by denying so many of them the spaces and opportunities that youth clubs used to provide.
Sue Tucker
Re: “The Saudis played a round and found out,” by Jay Elwes, TNW #505
LIV made a lot of golf pros very wealthy, many in the tail end of their careers on the other tours. One cannot blame them for taking these enormous sums of money.
Adam Primhak
