Skip to main content

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

A novel that asks: who belongs, and who decides?

Sharon Duggal’s absorbing Light Across The Plains explores family secrets and the borders that shape our lives

Sharon Duggal’s moving novel asks who gets to decide where we belong – and what we must leave behind to find freedom. Image: TNW

A sense of place means a lot to Sharon Duggal. After The Handsworth Times (South Asians in Birmingham, 1981) and Should We Fall Behind (outsiders sharing a street in southern England), her third novel, Light Across The Plains, is about borders – both crossing them, and how they deeply affect one family’s history.

The novel begins in 1989, with Lekha travelling to Berlin from Britain to sort through the belongings of her late Aunt Simran, whom she barely knew. This leads her to delve into her family history, taking us back to Simran’s life as an immigrant in 1960s London and then further back to India in the late 1940s and the upheaval of partition. 

“These Britishers are dividing our sons in preparation to divide our land, setting us against each other already, making us believe a border is necessary,” a character says. “We have always lived side by side – we may have differences in our diets and gods but we don’t need to be in separate lands to negotiate these things. We are brothers and sisters after all.”

The novel isn’t just about political borders but also about the boundaries caused by family, by gender, by culture. About the freedom to choose who you love, where you live, and what sort of life you want.

Light Across The Plains is epic in scope, taking in not just India’s partition but the reunification of Germany, as well as events in Paris and Prague in 1968. Berlin is viewed in retrospect as “an enclave of liberation surrounded by high walls and borders at the time; it allowed us to value our freedom above all else. We all drifted here, one by one over the years, each of us looking for some way of untying ourselves from threads which pull us only backwards.”

There is also a quieter, deeply personal politics running through the book; the politics of being a woman within a family. Across her story’s three generations, Duggal explores how expectations about duty, marriage, motherhood and respectability can shape – and sometimes restrict – women’s choices. The family becomes a political unit of its own, with power exercised not through laws but through expectation, loyalty, silence and the fear of disappointing those closest to you.

What makes this particularly effective is that Duggal doesn’t portray family tradition simply as oppressive; it can provide identity, security and belonging while simultaneously limiting individual freedom. The women therefore have to negotiate between what they owe their families and what they want for themselves. Their struggles are political precisely because they concern who has the right to make decisions about a woman’s life.

In this sense, the novel suggests that some of the most consequential borders are those drawn by families. As Lekha pieces together the lives of the women who came before her, we become increasingly aware that the version of the family’s history she has inherited is incomplete, and this leads to an eventual revelation at the end of the book. It shows us the ways families will protect, and sometimes distort, their own histories and bury secrets.

Light Across The Plains is not a political novel in the sense of offering a manifesto or providing all the answers. Its politics are quieter and, in some ways, more powerful. Duggal asks us to consider the human consequences of borders, migration, nationalism and social expectations.

Borders may be created by governments but they are lived in by individuals. And perhaps that is why Light Across The Plains resonates at a time when protests over immigration and asylum seekers have brought arguments about borders and belonging on to our streets.

Duggal’s novel offers a useful reminder of what can disappear when migration is discussed only in terms of numbers, policies and headlines. The people behind those statistics have histories, families and reasons for leaving one place for another. In that sense, this is not simply a novel about the past; it speaks directly to one of the most difficult and divisive questions facing Britain now: who belongs, and who gets to decide?

Absorbing and beautifully crafted, Light Across The Plains makes the huge political upheavals of the 20th century feel intensely personal. Duggal writes with warmth and empathy. Her themes, and these completely believable characters, will linger in your memory a long while after finishing the book.

Written with real emotional depth, and bringing history, family, and memory together with great subtlety, this is a rewarding, moving and calmly powerful book that feels very relevant to our moment.

Light Across The Plains by Sharon Duggal is published by Bluemoose

Hello. It looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience possible, please make sure any ad blockers are switched off, or add https://experience.tinypass.com to your trusted sites, and refresh the page.

If you have any questions or need help you can email us.

See inside the Bloody Immigrants edition

 Half Man Half Biscuit perform at the Mean Fiddler in Harlesden, 2003. Image: Brigitte Engl/Redferns/Getty

Travels with the cult of Half Man Half Biscuit

A new book follows the devoted army of fans of Britain’s most stubbornly independent band

A rare particle decay has opened a new window on the subatomic world. Image: Getty

The biggest mysteries of the universe just got a whole lot smaller

We’ve had the multiverse, the nanoverse and even the metaverse – but now we have the zeptoverse, and it might just contain the future of science